ACC Issues Statement of Solidarity; But Does It Mean Anything?

Did the ACC's Statement of Solidarity Actually Mean Anything? Well...

Did the ACC’s Statement of Solidarity Actually Mean Anything? Well…

As was heavily documented yesterday, the ACC‘s Council of Presidents issued a joint statement of solidarity, expressing their desire to work together to continue building a stronger athletic conference. The statement, which was backed by all 11 current committed members and all four future members, read:

“We, the undersigned presidents of the Atlantic Coast Conference, wish to express our commitment to preserve and protect the future of our outstanding league. We want to be clear that the speculation about ACC schools in negotiations or considering alternatives to the ACC are totally false. The presidents of the ACC are united in our commitment to a strong and enduring conference. The ACC has long been a leader in intercollegiate athletics, both academically and athletically, and the constitution of our existing and future member schools will maintain the ACC’s position as one of the nation’s premier conferences.”

So while it’s great to see all of the conference’s schools appear united amidst increased talk of further Big Ten (or even Big 12) raids, does it actually hold any water?

Unfortunately for those of us who are rooting for the ACC’s survival, the answer may be a resounding no, based on similar statements in the past, by other leagues feeling the expansion pressure. A sampling:

Does this mean that the ACC is doomed? Hardly. It’s still an incredibly strong league; one that possesses some of the strongest brands in college athletics and also has a pretty hefty $50 million exit fee attached to teams’ departure as well. And while the Big East was certainly dead in the water when their statement went out, the Big 12 ended up losing four teams and yet is still thriving today. They also had/have a grant of rights that locks up media rights for 13 years, which you’d think would’ve prevented any and all defections the second time around. So much for that…

Realistically, I do believe that the ACC is done losing teams for the time being, but in no way will that protect the league forever. While the conference is strong, there are plenty of issues left to resolve — an ACC cable network, a potential grant of rights agreement for the remainder of its television contract (same as the Big Ten and Big 12), enforcement of the $50M exit fee and third-party rights issued back to the schools. At least two of those are doable, and maybe a divisional realignment better suited to generate regional rivalries could also work to keep everyone happy. I’ve said this elsewhere, but it’s worth restating here too: Schools do not WANT to change conferences, especially when they’re already in one of the Power Five leagues. It’s a hefty time and financial investment, and they’d prefer the league they were in just do more to solidify itself. Maryland, swimming in a sea of debt, was an exception. They HAD TO leave, or else the university’s entire athletic department would’ve collapsed under the weight of football. For schools like Nebraska or Texas A&M, their choices were based on a perceived inequality in their previous leagues, and then aided by a financial windfall afterward.

Hoping I’m right, and the league rectifies its glaring issues, and the statement of solidarity is legit. We’ll see, though. As we all know, you’re never really sure of anything with conference realignment…

Comment, share this post, follow/like the blog and follow @JohnCassillo on Twitter


3 thoughts on “ACC Issues Statement of Solidarity; But Does It Mean Anything?

  1. Many Maryland fans (including this one) didn’t want to change conferences. It’s so frustrating … and it’ll probably be even more frustrating to me if the ACC responds by doing things it should have already done before Maryland left (most notably an ACC cable TV network).

    As for the statement of solidarity … it’s basically worthless, IMO. NC State could want to get out from under the shadow of North Carolina and Duke, and jump to the SEC. Florida State and Clemson could actually get that Big 12 offer (perhaps those two plus two others). Nobody really knows what will happen. Time will tell.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s